|
Career paths and management planning
The majority of managers are recruited through
internal promotion and networks. The process is often informal,
and today this appears primarily to favour men since the
majority of managers are men and they tend to choose other
men. If this pattern is to change, structured and transparent
processes are required to ensure that professional skills
rather than gender determine who is suitable.
The following list can help you develop a better, more
gender aware management planning process.
Transparent career paths
A gender perspective for job descriptions
Pool of potential managers
Appoint female line managers
Several women at the same level of
seniority
Twin leadership and management for limited
and defined periods
Start early
The role of the immediate superior
Good role models
Transparent career paths
In many organisations, visible opportunities that
allow people to seek promotion are limited. People generally
wait until they are asked. A Swedish study shows that 70
per cent of senior managers were offered a job or encouraged
to apply for one. This situation is probably the same in
other countries. The key to moving up the career ladder
is a broad and functioning network, and a high profile.
Career counselling should be a structured process and should
highlight alternative paths. Its main aim is to help the
individual develop by showing the direction in which he
or she should be heading.
Ensure that information about career paths and vacant positions
is made available, and that the mechanism of the promotion
system is transparent. This makes it easier for individuals
to take charge of planning their careers. People thinking
about taking on new challenges want to know what they are
applying for and what the job requires.
Job descriptions
Carefully prepared and designed job descriptions are a good
basis for recruiting managers. Be consistent, and work from
the organisation’s management management
philosophy when preparing clear and carefully written
job descriptions. (If your management philosophy has not
been documented, then write down your views of management
and demands made on existing and future managers.
Widen the recruiting pool by questioning previous requirements,
particularly from a gender
perspective. See also under recruiting.
Consider the following:
- Must new managers have the same educational qualifications
and experience as their predecessors?
- Do we consider the composition of the whole leadership
team when appointing a new member?
Pool of potential managers
Many organisations have structured processes for management
planning. The process often starts with peer review sessions
between managers and their subordinates, at which employees
can express their ambitions and managers provide their view
of the opportunities available. Suitable candidates are
then subjected to an appraisal process that includes interviews,
tests etc. This in turn can lead to investments in skills
enhancement and/or the candidates being placed in a pool
of potential managers. When new managers and other key persons
are to be appointed, they are selected from this internal
pool of potential managers.
Those who manage the pool of candidates need to be gender
aware so that they can nurture women identified as potential
managers and give them the same attention as male candidates.
They can encourage candidates to accept new areas of responsibility,
and support them. This includes providing career opportunities
for women with children who start careers when their children
are older.
Appoint female line managers
Many women become managers in the Human Resources, finance
or information fields. This has been one way for women to
obtain management positions, but it is now time to take
the next step and promote more women to operational positions.
Studies show that lack of experience of line management
with operational responsibility is one of the greatest obstacles
to women pursuing careers as senior executives. It is therefore
important for those who work with training and management
planning to consider which women would be suitable as line
managers, and to support them as they plan their careers.
It is also important to support women who are middle managers
by giving them positions and responsibility that can enhance
their career prospects.
Is the internal recruiting pool too small? Employ a number
of well-qualified young women and ensure that they gain
broad experience.
Encourage women to sit on internal and external boards
of directors. Offer training in board membership. Ensure
that women are given responsibility for important projects
and that they participate in management groups and working
groups. This gives individuals a higher profile and equips
them with good qualifications and experience.
Always more than one woman at the same level of
seniority!
A lone woman in an executive team is in a minority situation.
Some women can deal with this, but it can also result in
the woman being seen as ‘different’ and as a
representative not just for herself but for her sex. So,
recruit more women to the same level or group at the same
time. Once they have become established, conditions will
be right for additional women to apply to join the group.
Twin leadership and management for limited and defined
periods
Many managers look for alternative career paths and use
the image of a climbing frame instead of a career ladder.
The climbing frame allows mobility, and because nobody gets
stuck, people move in a way that is not possible in a hierarchy.
Individuals can adapt their careers so that they themselves
benefit and the organisation benefits as well. This model
also consider the various stages in life. Sideward or downward
steps are not important, as they are seen as a way of gaining
skills – a natural part of career development. One
way of formalising this system is to make people managers
for a limited period. Not only do the people who accept
these posts, and their colleagues, know that the post is
temporary, but the system also provides the opportunity
for several people to try their hand as managers without
losing face if they decide to do something else later on.
Another solution is ‘twin managers’. This involves
two people sharing a management post. The work can be shared
full or part time, all areas of responsibility can be shared,
or they can be split between the two participants.
Think carefully about how salary structures are affected
when managers rotate. Some companies pay a basic salary
with an increment for the managerial post.
Start early
Create a bridge between working life and schools. The image
of a company or sector is often shaped in schools and universities.
Discuss with students what constitutes good management and
why you want more women in management positions. Take every
opportunity to give talks about management at universities,
and make sure you are represented by somebody who is a role
model for the business.
Trainee programmes can be an excellent way of providing
the organisation with new management talent. It should be
remembered that programmes without a gender perspective
risk reinforcing existing perceptions. Make sure, therefore,
that the programme includes information about the significance
of gender and the different conditions that apply to men
and women. Ensure, too, that both men and women managers
and speakers participate in the programme.
Immediate superiors
Several studies (6) have shown that people’s first
manager is a key figure in the development of their careers,
both because this person influences how the new employee’s
abilities and potential are seen and confirmed, and because
the manager is the only person marketing the new employee
in the organisation. It is therefore important for individuals
themselves to choose a good manager and ensure that their
abilities are clearly perceived.
The employer can further support managers by explaining
why it is important to have women in senior positions, and
insist that managers promote women. It is also a question
of finding out which managers have a positive attitude towards
helping women grow, and focusing on them. It is therefore
important to promote the right men, too!
Immediate superiors may need support and training to help
staff in their career development. Be aware that women and
men can show their interest in different ways. A study of
Swedish and British companies showed that young men maintain
close contact with their manager to show off their accomplishments.
Women demonstrate their abilities through working well,
and believe that the manager will notice their good work.
Unfortunately, this is not always the case.
As a manager, then, you need to ensure that you are aware
of how all your staff work. Raise the question of a future
in management during career discussions! Is a mentor or
some other partner needed? Many women are never asked if
they are interested in promotion, because their manager
does not believe they can cope, due to family commitments.
Managers should not presume to make such decisions: it is
and must be the decision of the ndividual concerned.
A common misapprehension is that women’s self-esteem
is poorer than men’s and that they need more acknowledgement
and encouragement if they are to focus on what they are
actually capable of, and not just on their deficiencies.
Recent surveys show that women want to pursue a career as
much as men do. Younger female and male employees in particular
show the same desire to get ahead.
Some women need more time to make up their minds about
a management career and so decline the first time they are
asked. Give them time to think the matter over, and encourage
women to take the step! Find out why they said no –
it may be due to factors in the company structure or culture
that women dislike.
This is useful knowledge and providesopenings for seeking
changes in the organisational culture, for example, or for
bringing in other women at the same level.And if they still
say no? Discuss the matter again within the year –
they may have changed heir minds.Remember that all individuals
behave differently. If you meet women who immediately accept
promotion, do not be shocked or expect them to need persuading!
And there are just as many men as women who do not want
to be senior managers.
Good role models
Accurate description of the manager’s job is important.
A survey of how the media portrays managers shows how subconscious
expectations are passed on and reinforced daily. This has
consequences both for managers and for those who are thinking
about becoming one.One example is the myth that senior managers
are supermen or superwomen. This was the description of
a manager who died at his workplace: “It was always
best to ring him after normal working hours, about seven
in the evening. He even answered when he was at the gym.
He never worried about the time. You could ring back at
ten in the evening without himthinking it odd.”
A study of the media image of women shows that the same
actions are described differently depending on whether a
woman or a man is involved. A woman who is good at restructuring
and clearing up after a crisis is quickly referred to as
‘the cleaning lady’ or ‘iron ady’.
A man in the same position is called a ‘company surgeon’
or somebody who ‘rides out the storm’.
Consider:
- How do you think a manager should be, how should work
and leisure be divided?
- How do we talk about managers?
- What are our preconceptions of femininity and masculinity?
- Do these preconceptions tally with real managers?
Appoint female managers as mentors and coaches. Draw attention
to managers who deviate from gender stereotypes in internal
and external communications. For example: senior managers
who do their job during normal working hours and who take
parental leave, a woman who admits that power and responsibility
are fun. Ensure that they receive support if they are criticised
for their choices!
Men are important role models for women. With this in mind,
men need not see women as a threat, and gaps can be bridged
through exchanges of experience. Older male managers can
become mentors and sounding boards for both female and male
younger colleagues pursuing a career.
There is a need for more good examples of how more women
can be brought to the top. One of the most important reasons
given by companies participating in Women to the Top was
that they saw gender diversity as a success factor and something
that improved their company’s image. Share your success
stories! You don’t have to be good at everything to
be proud of something.
|